Black Christians : Tithing and New Covenant Giving - Part 2

Panoramic

Member
MEMBER
Nov 9, 2014
9
3
Some Christians believe that Abraham's tenth to Melchizedek set a precedent for giving 10% of their income in the New Covenant. This belief is problematic for a few reasons:

1. God did not command Abraham to give a tenth of the war spoils to Melchizedek. Abraham more than likely gave a tenth to Melchizedek out of ancient custom. In ancient times, it was custom to give a portion of war spoils to a head of State. Ancient people sometimes gave a tenth, because we have ten fingers, which made it convenient to count in tens.

2. Tithing was not a part of Abraham’s covenant with God. If you study all of the passages about Abraham’s covenant with God, you will see that tithing isn’t mentioned. The Lord never commanded Abraham to give one-tenth of anything as a part of his covenant. This proves that tithing is not an “eternal principle.” If it were, then God would have required it of Abraham. Yet tithing was not included in Abraham’s covenant with God.

3. Abraham did not give a tenth of war spoils to Melchizedek as a means of being blessed or becoming prosperous. Abraham was already blessed and prosperous BEFORE he ever gave a tenth to Melchizedek. This proves that Abraham was blessed and prosperous WITHOUT tithing.

4. God blessed Abraham because of his FAITH – not because he gave a tenth of war spoils to Melchizedek.

5. Genesis 14 is the only mention of Abraham giving a tenth to anyone. We cannot speculate or read into Scripture that Abraham was a “faithful tither” or tithed regularly. His tenth to Melchizedek was a unique one-time event. The Bible does not say that Abraham ever gave a tenth to Melchizedek again.

6. Abraham didn’t give a tenth of his personal income or personal property. He gave a tenth of someone else’s property (war spoils), so his tithe to Melchizedek cost him nothing. He gave away someone else’s property, not his own.

7. Abraham didn’t keep the rest of the war spoils. He gave it back to the original owners (minus the portion that was given to the men who fought with him), because he didn’t want pagan kings to brag that they made him rich.

In the next installment, we’re going to dig into Hebrews 7:1-17 and see how Melchizedek foreshadowed Jesus Christ, our King and High Priest. Our Savior is the ultimate reason why Genesis 14 was written down, not because God wanted us to give 10% of our income in the New Covenant!
 

Clyde C Coger Jr

going above and beyond
PREMIUM MEMBER
Nov 17, 2006
58,484
11,885
www.amazon.com
Occupation
Speaker/Teacher/Author
Some Christians believe that Abraham's tenth to Melchizedek set a precedent for giving 10% of their income in the New Covenant. This belief is problematic for a few reasons:

1. God did not command Abraham to give a tenth of the war spoils to Melchizedek. Abraham more than likely gave a tenth to Melchizedek out of ancient custom. In ancient times, it was custom to give a portion of war spoils to a head of State. Ancient people sometimes gave a tenth, because we have ten fingers, which made it convenient to count in tens.

2. Tithing was not a part of Abraham’s covenant with God. If you study all of the passages about Abraham’s covenant with God, you will see that tithing isn’t mentioned. The Lord never commanded Abraham to give one-tenth of anything as a part of his covenant. This proves that tithing is not an “eternal principle.” If it were, then God would have required it of Abraham. Yet tithing was not included in Abraham’s covenant with God.

3. Abraham did not give a tenth of war spoils to Melchizedek as a means of being blessed or becoming prosperous. Abraham was already blessed and prosperous BEFORE he ever gave a tenth to Melchizedek. This proves that Abraham was blessed and prosperous WITHOUT tithing.

4. God blessed Abraham because of his FAITH – not because he gave a tenth of war spoils to Melchizedek.

5. Genesis 14 is the only mention of Abraham giving a tenth to anyone. We cannot speculate or read into Scripture that Abraham was a “faithful tither” or tithed regularly. His tenth to Melchizedek was a unique one-time event. The Bible does not say that Abraham ever gave a tenth to Melchizedek again.

6. Abraham didn’t give a tenth of his personal income or personal property. He gave a tenth of someone else’s property (war spoils), so his tithe to Melchizedek cost him nothing. He gave away someone else’s property, not his own.

7. Abraham didn’t keep the rest of the war spoils. He gave it back to the original owners (minus the portion that was given to the men who fought with him), because he didn’t want pagan kings to brag that they made him rich.

In the next installment, we’re going to dig into Hebrews 7:1-17 and see how Melchizedek foreshadowed Jesus Christ, our King and High Priest. Our Savior is the ultimate reason why Genesis 14 was written down, not because God wanted us to give 10% of our income in the New Covenant!


Correct Panoramic, the commentary reveals much truth about the manner in which Abraham tithed and why.

...
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Panoramic Black Christians : Tithing and New Covenant Giving - Part 1 Christian Study Group 1
Panoramic Black Christians : Upcoming Series About Tithing and New Covenant Giving Christian Study Group 3
Black-king Black Hebrew Israelites : The Law of tithing is done away with. Black Hebrew Israelites Study Group 1
rapunzal24 Black Christians : Tithing. Christian Study Group 136
Destee Black Spirituality Religion : Can You Get To Heaven Without $$ Tithing? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 31
Kemetstry Black Entertainment : ALIEN COVENANT Black Entertainment 0
Keita Kenyatta Black Spirituality Religion : The Ark of The Covenant, Ancient Technology !! Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 0
I Ethiopia : Lost Ark of the Covenant traced to Ethiopia Ethiopia 3
G Black People : Mike speaks out on the covenant with black america Black People Open Forum 0
G Black People : New Treaty In the Making Covenant on Environment and Development Black People Open Forum 0
Fine1952 Black Authors : "Covenant" Short Stories - Authors - Writing 0
M Black People : Covenant with Black America 2006* Black People Open Forum 1
Akilah Black People : The Covenant With Black America Black People Open Forum 53
KWABENA Pan Africanism : THE LOST ARK OF THE COVENANT African American History Culture 39
dnommo Black Poetry : ark of covenant Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 7
R Black Poetry : She get teased worldly her boss let her leave early from work there's some flirt but dumb jerk keep her alert she's a queen right but she's not giving Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
C Black People : Ain't Nobody That Is Against Reparation/Repatriation Doing Or Giving Anything To Black Afrikans That Is Worthwhile To Your Liberation!!! Black People Open Forum 0
OldSoul Black People : 11 mins with the Deacons for Defense and Justice - Giving Honor Black People Open Forum 0
Fine1952 Black People : Mis-Giving -- The Truth Behind Thanksgiving Black People Open Forum 18
S Black Poetry : Giving props a healthy habit Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
R Black Poetry : See jive that be alive like living tissue giving the issue a pay attention look not tof mention hook Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 2
candeesweet Black Poetry : Giving up Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
Al D Black People : Young African Brother Giving Back In Kansas City, Mo. Black People Open Forum 0
SouthsideIrish Food Discussion : Giving up charcoal Food Discussion and Recipes 2
shaka64 Black Education / Schools : Teen Secretly Records his Substitute Teacher Giving Him Oral Sex on her First Day at School - See mo Black Education / Schools 30
KaHotep Black Poetry : Giving Birth They Follow Suit Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
MsInterpret Black People : Miami-Dade Police Tackle, Choke 14-Year-Old For Giving Them “Dehumanizing Stare” Black People Open Forum 5
R Black Poetry : Step swift to accept gifts the power of giving but Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 2
legit-writer Black Relationships : Giving Your Partner Access to Your Accounts Black Relationships 11
cherryblossom Black Authors : Giving Back by Valaida Fullwood Short Stories - Authors - Writing 0
Zaiyah's House Audio Video Web Conferencing : destee.tv : Donny Hathaway- Giving Up Audio Video Web Conferencing 0
Destee Audio Video Web Conferencing : destee.tv : Anita Baker - Giving You The Best That I've Got Audio Video Web Conferencing 0
S Black Education / Schools : Are teachers giving 100%? Black Education / Schools 26
HODEE Black People : Your reward is in the giving Black People Open Forum 1
triniti424 Black People : ~~~~~ GIVING LOVE WHERE LOVE IS DUE ~~~~~ Black People Open Forum 65
Sekhemu Black Spirituality Religion : Mojubar: Giving homage and Pouring libation Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 1
Chief Elder Osiris Chief Elder Osiris : Incapable Of Giving A Divine Opinion Chief Elder Osiris 0
A Destee Network : Adiama Services & Tours: Giving & Receiving to Empower Afrikan Communities Destee Network : 0
$$RICH$$ Black Haiku : GIVING UP! Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 4
P Black People : HAPPY THANK YOU'S GIVING PEOPLE Black People Open Forum 0
dattaswami1 Black Spirituality Religion : God and His constitution are giving information of the path desired by you Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 1
A Black Relationships : i dont know it anymore (sumthimes i feel lost and feel like loosing it giving up) Black Relationships 22
KWABENA Black People : GIVING - AND BEING BLESSED Black People Open Forum 4
Destee The Front Porch : Giving Love to our Moderators The Front Porch 32
FINDLOVEINME Black Poetry : GIVING UP YOUR *** IN 24 HRS OR LESS Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 11
N What is the best advice you have heard or was giving to you growing up Black Parenting 4
D Black People : giving a subject can be hard..how about we Black People Open Forum 2
$$RICH$$ Black Haiku : Giving Thankz Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 6
S Black Poetry : I'm giving this page a transfusion of my thoughts Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 4
$$RICH$$ Black Poetry : GIVING it up !!!! Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 8
Similar threads


















































Destee Chat

Latest profile posts

Black and Latino custodial workers @ the Capitol Bldg said it was degrading to clean up the debris left by white supremacist who violently stormed the Capitol Bldg. They even had to clean up smeared feces. One staffer said they were used to cleaning up after white supremacist (referring to racist Congressional members). Those who were there that day feared for their life b/c they weren't given any protection.
Mother Jones posted a list of "law makers" nationwide who promoted/assisted in the insurrection on our government. ALL should be ousted, stripped of pensions, charged with sedition and felony murder.
If black folks are present at a crime, whether they participated or not, they're charged with as many violations as white folks can conjure up. Felony murder is top of their list. Why not for white domestic terrorist?
25,000 National Guardsmen are set up to protect for Biden/Harris inauguration! Authorities are AGAIN saying that white domestic terrorist are the largest threat in American and to the democratic process.
NOT Black Lives Matter protestors, NOT even foreign terrorist, but American grown white men who are angry about all the white privilege they have.
Twitter is now locking accounts for unusual activity when there is no unusual activity. Apparently if you post to much to soon, it triggers their spider hairs. Never mind that it's (or was) a platform to post information and opinions, now it's just a flat bed from the ghost-of-trump-past. Jack Dorsey/Twitter should be charged with giving trump the media to incite a resurrection against the United States government.
18 family members tested positive for COVID after a holiday party in Pennsylvania, including a one year old baby. YES of course they were white. The mother knew she had "something", but during a world pandemic she didn't think it was COVID. This is insane! They just keep spreading it!
Top