Black People : 'Selma' Ignores the Radical Grassroots Politics of the Civil Rights Movement

RAPTOR

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Sep 12, 2009
6,840
3,592
"Hollywood loves the great man narrative, but the civil rights movement was never about top-down leadership "

By Jesse McCarthy
(exerpt)
In it’s rush to enshrine and reconfirm the charismatic male leadership of the movement, this film fails
to honor the great female fountainheads of that movement, Septima Clark and Ella Baker, and women
like Fannie Lou Hamer in the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party, whose work on voter-
registration and literacy, through the Citizenship Schools, were the true incubators of activism and
irrigators of the Civil Rights movement. At a time when men still unthinkingly expected the women to
take notes as the men talked politics at meetings, Baker, the outspoken guiding spirit of SNCC, proved
an indispensable leader, instrumental at every level in the success of Freedom Summer.

What it comes down to is that Selma expresses at every turn the political perspective of the black
middle class, which prefers to perceive the civil rights struggle through the lens of individual dignity
and negotiation, as opposed to collective urgency and direct action. There is nothing inherently wrong
with this, both currents were, and indeed remain, important drivers of change. But it explains the
film’s contemptuous handling of any whiff of radical politics. The groundbreaking work of SNCC, for
example, is dismissed as hot-headed petulance. An utterly bizarre performance by Nigel Thatch of
Malcolm X presents him simultaneously as rakish and emasculated, a potential threat to a good
woman, without any trace of a threat to white supremacy; while the film redacts Stokely Carmichael
from the record entirely. Lowndes County, Alabama comes up several times, but those who don’t
know their movement history will not know he was there, or recognize it as the birthplace of the Black
Panther party.

Read more: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120685/selma-lessons-ava-duvernays-film
 

chuck

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Aug 9, 2003
13,471
2,160
Better comments from truly knowledgeable people on such subjects are also needed and wanted via these forums too!

FYI
 

chuck

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Aug 9, 2003
13,471
2,160
One and all just have to do their own homework, regardless of the mediums of choice, etc.

FYI
 

CosmicMessenger

Banned
MEMBER
Aug 24, 2013
3,190
428
"Hollywood loves the great man narrative, but the civil rights movement was never about top-down leadership "

By Jesse McCarthy
(exerpt)
In it’s rush to enshrine and reconfirm the charismatic male leadership of the movement, this film fails
to honor the great female fountainheads of that movement, Septima Clark and Ella Baker, and women
like Fannie Lou Hamer in the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party, whose work on voter-
registration and literacy, through the Citizenship Schools, were the true incubators of activism and
irrigators of the Civil Rights movement. At a time when men still unthinkingly expected the women to
take notes as the men talked politics at meetings, Baker, the outspoken guiding spirit of SNCC, proved
an indispensable leader, instrumental at every level in the success of Freedom Summer.

What it comes down to is that Selma expresses at every turn the political perspective of the black
middle class, which prefers to perceive the civil rights struggle through the lens of individual dignity
and negotiation, as opposed to collective urgency and direct action. There is nothing inherently wrong
with this, both currents were, and indeed remain, important drivers of change. But it explains the
film’s contemptuous handling of any whiff of radical politics. The groundbreaking work of SNCC, for
example, is dismissed as hot-headed petulance. An utterly bizarre performance by Nigel Thatch of
Malcolm X presents him simultaneously as rakish and emasculated, a potential threat to a good
woman, without any trace of a threat to white supremacy; while the film redacts Stokely Carmichael
from the record entirely. Lowndes County, Alabama comes up several times, but those who don’t
know their movement history will not know he was there, or recognize it as the birthplace of the Black
Panther party.

Read more: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120685/selma-lessons-ava-duvernays-film
When I saw that Oprah was in the movie, I figured that it was garbage.

Thanks for the warning.

Peace!
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : Selma, the birthplace of modern democracy in America African American History Culture 0
OldSoul OldSoul : The Almost Forgotten Selma March OldSoul 1
RAPTOR Black People : Obama’s Selma Song: America Is Not Racist – It’s Just Ferguson Black People Open Forum 0
chuck Black People : Selma Retrospective Idealizes The Past And Doesn't Usher In The Future! Black People Open Forum 6
RAPTOR Black People : Selma: Black History According to Oprah Black People Open Forum 12
OldSoul OldSoul : Selma Trailer remix OldSoul 0
Kemetstry Black Entertainment : SELMA Black Entertainment 13
OldSoul OldSoul : Youth and teachers played a significant role in the Selma Movement OldSoul 0
Fine1952 Black Entertainment : Selma --- Oprah's Non-Bioptics Movie about MLK, Jr. Black Entertainment 26
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : Ben Carson’s great betrayal: How he ignores history in favor of the Republican Party Black People Politics 101
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Obama ignores clemency for political prisoners Black People Politics 0
C Black Relationships : Boyfriend ignores text messages Black Relationships 15
K Congo : World ignores Republic of Congo's crisis - U.N. Republic of the Congo 1
O Black People Politics : The Black Radical Tradition Black People Politics 49
S Black People : What is the Actual Hidden Agenda of the Radical Right? Black People Open Forum 0
Liberty Law Forum : A Society Without Prisons: Envisioning the Radical Philosophy of Angela Davis Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 5
RAPTOR Black People : The Black Radical Tradition Confronts False Leadership and "Stealth History" Black People Open Forum 0
RAPTOR Black People : Molefi Asante’s Insane War on BAR and the Black Radical Tradition Black People Open Forum 55
cherryblossom African American History Culture : Want To Start A Revolution? - Radical Women, Black Freedom Struggle African American History Culture 7
RAPTOR Black People : Martin Luther King "radical revolution of values" sermon Black People Open Forum 0
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Radical Politics: The Dr. King America Fails To Talk About. Black People Politics 4
OldSoul OldSoul : Sunday Noon ET CHAT Topic: Ms Taylor and Rosa the Radical OldSoul 0
Chief Elder Osiris Chief Elder Osiris : There Is A Conspiracy Against Black People and Radical White Americans. Chief Elder Osiris 0
Amnat77 Nigeria : Radical Women Shut Down Shell in Nigeria, MEND Leader Assassinated Nigeria 5
R Black Poetry : Being Radical Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 2
OmowaleX BOB MARLEY-ROOTS RADICAL Honoring Black Ancestors 0
river Vegetable - Fruit - Recipe : Radical Lunch Food Discussion and Recipes 0
$$RICH$$ Black People : Happy Birthday (Radical Faith) Black People Open Forum 15
I Black Spirituality Religion : Question For Radical Faith Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 30
L Black Poetry : RUN! to Radical.... Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 8
A Black Poetry : Dr. King’s “RADICAL” legacy…Understanding the message Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 6
Similar threads































Destee Chat

Latest profile posts

Ms Drea wrote on I_AM_HER's profile.
Welcome To Destee!! Love and Blessings!!
Sup, Fam. Peace.
Destee wrote on Ms Drea's profile.
Sister ... please forgive me, I just been so krazee lately ... I love you ... :love:
Destee wrote on Titoub's profile.
Hi My Friend! How are you? Welcome Home! :wave:
Destee wrote on Monetary's profile.
Hey Money - where ya been? Tell us everything ... :beer:
Top