going above and beyond
Feb 19, 2001
Health Published: Dec. 7, 2016
MSU study uncovers real culprits behind Flint water crisis
Contact(s): Rick Sadler College of Human Medicine office: (810) 600-5674, Geri Kelley College of Human Medicine office: (616) 233-1678 cell: (616) 350-7976, Sarina Gleason Media Communications office: (517) 355-9742
Many believe the events leading to the lead poisoning of Flint’s drinking water began in April 2014, when it started drawing from the Flint River. Others believe it began in November 2011, when Gov. Rick Snyder appointed an emergency manager to take control of Flint’s government.
While those actions were immediate and important factors in the crisis, Richard Sadler, an assistant professor of public health and co-author of a new Michigan State University study, has found that in order to understand its real genesis, one must go back decades and examine a series of governmental, social and economic policies that led to the city’s decline and ultimately to the contamination.

“The main point is that, although we tend to think of the water crisis as proximately caused by the switch to the Flint River or the emergency manager law, we need to think about more distant political and economic causes,” Sadler said, who is also a medical geographer in the College of Human Medicine.
The study is published in the journal Environmental Justice in collaboration with Andrew Highsmith, the author of "Demolition Means Progress: Flint, Michigan and the Fate of the American Metropolis," a book about the city’s decline.
While the loss of the auto industry certainly contributed to Flint’s deterioration, racial segregation, suburban sprawl and the resulting political fragmentation were major factors leading to the water crisis, he indicated.

As Flint’s population dropped from nearly 200,000 to fewer than 100,000 residents, many of them low income, the city was hemmed in by the suburbs and unable to grow through annexation after mid-century changes to state law.
“Local governance changes in the ‘60s and ‘70s were the lynchpins in Flint’s decline,” Sadler said. “The suburbs – supported by the state – basically strangled Flint’s ability to effectively grow and manage its finances.”
Intentionally or unwittingly, state and local officials followed an urban development model created by the late Charles Tiebout, an economist and geographer who promoted competition – rather than cooperation – among local governments for residents and investment.
“In other contexts where a region is growing, the Tiebout model can work,” Sadler said, “but it is particularly ill-suited to shrinking urban regions with stagnant tax bases.”

State and federal laws and land use policies encouraged suburban sprawl by offering subsidies that duplicated infrastructure that already existed in Flint. As residents fled to the more-affluent suburbs, they left Flint behind with a declining tax base and fewer residents to pay for maintenance of the infrastructure. Cuts in state revenue sharing also made it even more difficult for the city to adequately maintain its water system.
In the study, Sadler and Highsmith found that the fragmentation of the Flint metropolitan region – supported through a variety of housing and land use policies over many decades – created the conditions whereby suburbs were absolved of responsibility for Flint’s decades-long economic crisis.
As a result, Flint’s more affluent suburbs continued to prosper while Flint grew poorer and experienced infrastructure decline.

Both authors stated that the crisis is a classic example of an environmental injustice, as policies were set in motion which led to the creation of a politically separate and majority-black municipality with concentrated poverty, while nearby municipalities – most of them overwhelmingly white – accepted little responsibility for the legacy costs created by the region’s starkly uneven patterns of metropolitan development.
A better approach, Sadler said, would be a form of “federated regionalism,” which would preserve local government autonomy while also encouraging coordinated regional planning and consolidation of services.
“Failure to address the causes of declining urban areas will lead to further deterioration, not only in central cities, but in suburbs, he said. “Troublingly, suburbs could experience more severe issues maintaining quality of life because they already serve much lower densities, so their infrastructure is more costly per person to maintain.”
Sadler recalled the prophetic words of a black Flint city commissioner in 1969: “Those of you who feel you will escape by running to suburbia, beware…blight recognizes no border lines.”
“It should be a lesson learned that when we, as an urbanized society, go frolicking off into the farmland and ignore the infrastructure we already built, problems will inevitably arise,” Sadler said. “And ignoring these problems eventually will come back and bite you.”


Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Queenie Black People : Former MSU Basketball Star Caught in Sexual Assault Net Black People Open Forum 0
R Black Poetry : Snack is a small meal cornflakes make it all real rattle the street I'm from Battle creek so kneel to the words see a girl with hips and lips and chi Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
Fine1952 Health and Wellness : The REAL Devils Black Health and Wellness 50
C Black People : Being Divinely True And Real Black People Open Forum 1
Queenie Law Forum : How real is the movie, "Black and Blue"? Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 0
C Black People : Is God Real Or Is Just Our Higher Self? Black People Open Forum 0
A Black People : WAKANDA 4 REAL! Black People Open Forum 18
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : The Myth Was $150,000 in Fraud. The Real Story Is More Interesting African American History Culture 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : Tech addiction is real. We psychologists need to take it seriously Black Health and Wellness 0
F Black People : Is real empowerment truly possible if Black men and Black women are disconnected from each other? Black People Open Forum 6
MicTheory Black People Politics : Why I believe white extinction is real and climate change is the catalyst! Black People Politics 11
OldSoul Black People : The True Adventures of the Real Uncle Tom Black People Open Forum 0
Louise Cosper Law Forum : A MATTER OF REAL CONCERN FOR ALL – THE BACKGROUND DATABASE Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 1
chuck Black People Politics : Can We Truly Give Props To The Real Black Panthers Of The 1960's? Black People Politics 5
chuck Black Entertainment : Can You Truly Give Props To The Real Black Panthers Of The Sixties? Black Entertainment 0
Lunar Cycle Black Education / Schools : Train vs. Vehicle Collisions and Trespass: The Real Education Black Education / Schools 0
Mario William vitale Black Positive People : Keeping It Real Black People Doing Positive Things 0
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Yvette Carnell: Black Spending Power Is an Illusion, but the Racial Wealth Gap is Real Black People Politics 1
BLAQ LOVE POURAHTREE Black Poetry : Outlaw: Definition of a Real Player Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 8
BLAQ LOVE POURAHTREE Black Poetry : Outlaw: Just Being Real Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
BLAQ LOVE POURAHTREE Black Poetry : Reality Is Realer Than Real Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
BLAQ LOVE POURAHTREE Black Poetry : Real Love: Two Lineages as One Tree Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
nilevalley Black People Politics : This is why the people of Kenya Africa would tell Donald Trump climate change is a real fact! Black People Politics 3
Queenie Black People : Let's be real about the hate - bigotry - racism Black People Open Forum 50
jamesfrmphilly Black Entertainment : Lee Daniels says racism isn’t ‘real’ because he doesn’t ’embrace’ it Black Entertainment 4
Liberty Black Money Business Jobs : From Banks to Beauty Products, The #BuyBlack Movement Is Real Black Money Business Jobs 0
alcase Black People Politics : Will The Real Hillary Clinton Please Stand Up Black People Politics 4
nilevalley Black People : Is it fake or the real thing? Black People Open Forum 1
tarhaka bey Black People : What are your thoughts on this thread as a real Man or Woman Black People Open Forum 21
S African American History Culture : The Real Reason Slavery Ended - The Gullah Wars African American History Culture 1
S Black People : The Real Reason Slavery Ended - The Gullah Wars Black People Open Forum 1
AACOOLDRE Brother AACOOLDRE : Understanding the real Amen AACOOLDRE 1
umbrarchist Black Education / Schools : Education and Progress in the REAL World Black Education / Schools 17
AACOOLDRE Brother AACOOLDRE : Chelsea Clinton real dad is Web Hubbell AACOOLDRE 1
Clyde C Coger Jr Food Discussion : You're eating a lot of fake, rotten olive oil — here's how to find the real stuff Food Discussion and Recipes 1
chuck Black People : What Is The Real Basis Of Black Culture Today?!? Black People Open Forum 1
Liberty Black People : Sundiata Cha-Jua/Real Talk: Breaking the cycle of gun violence in the black community Black People Open Forum 3
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People : Michelle Obama Keeps It Real: 'I Wake Up In a House Built By Slaves' Black People Open Forum 6
T Black Positive People : REAL YOUNG PEOPLE REVOLUTION 2016!!! URGENT HELP Black People Doing Positive Things 2
chuck Black People : Pop Culture Only Mimics Our Real Experiences! Black People Open Forum 0
R Black Poetry : to have real fate is an ideal state if it befalls earlier in life I pause // frequent becase of rece Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
chuck Black People Politics : Who Do You Consider Our Peoples Real Leaders In 2016?!? Black People Politics 2
Liberty Black Relationships : Can Real Love Die? Black Relationships 3
MS234 Black People : Erin Andrews $55M mocks real pain and suffering by families like Eric Garner and Freddie Gray Black People Open Forum 22
Chaya Chaim Black Positive People : *************** address the real "coons " Black People Doing Positive Things 7
OldSoul OldSoul : Judge Joe Brown tells How James Earl Ray wasn't the real Killer of Martin Luther King OldSoul 2
Al D Black People : Who are the real terrorists in this country or the world for that matter? Black People Open Forum 4
jamesfrmphilly Black Positive People : Zaevion Dobson - a real hero !!!!!!! Black People Doing Positive Things 5
chuck Black Spirituality Religion : The real threats are religious extremists in 2015 Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 1
Destee Black People : Goodnight Don't Let The Bed Bugs Bite ... Have you ever seen a bed bug in real life? Black People Open Forum 2
Similar threads

Destee Chat

Latest profile posts

Ms Drea wrote on I_AM_HER's profile.
Welcome To Destee!! Love and Blessings!!
Sup, Fam. Peace.
Destee wrote on Ms Drea's profile.
Sister ... please forgive me, I just been so krazee lately ... I love you ... :love:
Destee wrote on Titoub's profile.
Hi My Friend! How are you? Welcome Home! :wave:
Destee wrote on Monetary's profile.
Hey Money - where ya been? Tell us everything ... :beer: