Black People : Grand Jury Indictments DO NOT Fit the Crime!!NYPD Murder of Sean Bell -

Goddess Auset333

Feb 9, 2007
NYPD Murder of Sean Bell

Grand Jury Indictments DO NOT Fit the Crime!!
On March 19, the Queens DA unsealed the grand jury's findings on the NYPD cops who killed Sean Bell on November 25 last year and severely wounded his friends, Trent Benefield and Joseph Guzman. Two of the cops—Michael Oliver, who fired 31 times, and Gescard Isnora, who was the first to shoot and fired 11 times—were charged with first- and second-degree manslaughter, as well as assault and reckless endangerment. The third cop, Marc Cooper, was charged only with reckless endangerment, a misdemeanor. If Oliver and Isnora are found guilty on all charges, they will face a maximum of 25 years in jail.

The view of the cops is that NO charges should have come down. Michael Palladino, the head of the Detectives Endowment Association, argues that those cops were placed in a situation where they had to make a split second decision to deal with what could've been a threat to their lives.

Others, including various DAs, have said that the manslaughter charges (which are significantly less heavy than murder) are appropriate. They say these cops didn't set out to kill anyone that night, so Sean's death was only a by-product of actions they took to try to deal with a potentially dangerous situation. Some of them even say that people who oppose police brutality should be glad these cops were charged with manslaughter and not murder, because it's very unlikely that cops would be convicted of murder, but they might be convicted of manslaughter.

But the truth of the matter is: Charges should have been brought down on ALL the cops involved in the murder of Sean Bell. And the charges against the three cops are NOT AT ALL commensurate with the horrible crime they committed.

A charge of first-degree manslaughter requires intent to injure one or more persons and someone being killed in the course of that being done. The difference between that and a charge of murder is that the intent has to be not only to injure, but to kill. This intent to kill doesn't mean that these cops had to have decided earlier that night to kill Sean. It means that their intent in carrying out the actions that led to Sean's death had to be to kill someone, not just to injure somebody.

These cops shot 50 bullets at Bell, Benefield, and Guzman. One of them fired 31 bullets, emptying a full clip, reloading his gun, and emptying a second clip. Another fired 11 shots. Does this sound like they only wanted to injure, not kill their targets?? You shoot at somebody 31 times, or even 11 times—you're clearly trying to kill them, not injure or just disable them.

And why did two of the cops involved in the shooting get no charges at all? All five of the cops trailed Bell, Benefield, and Guzman to their car that night and blocked them in with two unmarked police vehicles. Some fired fewer bullets than others did, but they all were part of the squad that surrounded the car, blocked it in and then unleashed a rain of deadly bullets.

These actions meet the legal system's own criteria for murder charges. And the reason these cops didn't get charged with murder is that they are cops—and the system has an entirely different "criteria" and approach when cops kill and maim than when ordinary people are suspected of criminal activity.

When the legal system deals with ordinary people, the DAs go for the most serious charges they can get, and they charge everyone who was even remotely involved with those serious charges.

What does it take under this system to get a cop indicted and convicted for murder? Many people are asking that very question. Here you have a case where unarmed people got hit with a hail of murderous gunfire, and two of the victims survived to tell how this murderous assault went down. On top of this, there were massive outpourings of people taking to the streets demanding justice in this case. And the most serious charge that results from this is manslaughter?

They are rubbing this in people's faces right now, telling us that it's better that the cops were charged with manslaughter and not murder because it's essentially impossible to get cops convicted of murder—of intent to kill. So we should be glad that we got any charges on these cops, and we should take what we can get. Of course following this "experts'" logic, you'd conclude you also can't get cops convicted for first-degree manslaughter, because that too involves a question of intent, even if "only" intent to injure. The logic of this logic is that it would be better still if these cops had been given even LESS serious charges—maybe no felony charges at all, maybe just misdemeanors like reckless endangerment—so there would be an even better chance that these cops would be convicted of at least something!

This is logic that the people must reject. We should not accept that the cops' actions that night were anything less than what they actually were—MURDER. And even the fact that these cops were indicted with anything at all is because of the massive outrage and response from the people.

These charges don't guarantee that any of the cops will be punished for what they did that night. And if there is to be any justice delivered in this case, the masses of people are going to have to fight tooth and nail for it.

Steve Yip
P.O. Box 941, Knickerbocker Station
New York, New York 10002-0900
866-841-9139 x2670,

It's time to throw off the chains of oppression,
and get with the emancipators of humanity!

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
RAPTOR Black People : • Charles Barkley Supports Police After Ferguson Grand Jury Decision • Black People Open Forum 78
RAPTOR Black People Politics : President Obama: Grand jury decision not an ‘excuse for violence’ in Ferguson Black People Politics 3
KingSango Black People : How to get past the Ferguson Grand Jury decision. Black People Open Forum 0
RAPTOR Law Forum : "It is Officially Open Season on Black Folks": Legal Expert Decries Handling of Wilson Grand Jury Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 4
OldSoul OldSoul : An Open Letter from Protesters On The Grand Jury Decision (11.24.14) OldSoul 10
shaka64 Black People : Grand jury decides NOT to indict cop who killed John Crawford at Walmart Black People Open Forum 1
jamesfrmphilly Law Forum : Grand jury indicts police officer in shooting of ex-FAMU player Jonathan Ferrell Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 1
jamesfrmphilly Law Forum : Grand jury declines to indict NC cop who killed former FAMU footballer Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 1
Destee Law Forum : Grand Jury Indicts 35 In Connection With Atlanta Public Schools Cheating Scandal Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 2
Writeous1 Black People : As Grand Jury Clears White Plains Police in Kenneth Chamberlain’s Death, New Tape Shows Fatal Raid Black People Open Forum 2
Keita Kenyatta Black People : The Lookout Trayvon Martin shooting: no grand jury for Zimmerman Black People Open Forum 4
PatriceCQueen Black People : grand jury testimony about incidents concerning persons connected to penn state Black People Open Forum 1
R Black Poetry : Plan to have a companion and like the grand canyon folks visit my quotes explicit and make them hopes exquisite ride in a bold hummer and like a whole Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
Mario William vitale Black Entertainment : Grand Master Flash Fresh Style Black Entertainment 0
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : The National Museum of African American History and Culture: Grand Opening African American History Culture 44
RAPTOR The Police : California Moves Towards Banning Grand Juries for Police Killings Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 3
chuck Black People : Is This A Grand Bargain For Black Detroiters Too?!? Black People Open Forum 1
chuck Black People : Detroit's 'Grand Bargain' Is For Us Too?!? Black People Open Forum 0
$$RICH$$ Black Sports : Australia Open Serena Williams won her 19th Grand Slam title Black Sports 7
CosmicMessenger Black Entertainment : Third Coast Kings - West Grand Boulevard Black Entertainment 0
chuck Black People Politics : Just Who Will Be The Winners (Or Losers) Via Detroit's 'Grand Bargain' Swepstakes? Black People Politics 15
Omowale Jabali Black Spirituality Religion : Tetrad: A Blood Moon In The Grand Cardinal Cross Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 9
jamesfrmphilly Black People Politics : my grand mother told me…. Black People Politics 1
Keita Kenyatta Egypt : Egyptian caverns in The Grand Canyon - David Hatcher Childress Pt 1/12 Egypt 7
skuderjaymes African American History Culture : At The Feet Of The Grand Masters: Dr. Ben, Dr. Clarke, Dr. Jackson African American History Culture 9
Feather Podcasts / MP3s / Audio : Grand-Puba--Sarah-Martinez/REALITY CHECK!!!!!! Audio Video Web Conferencing 0
1poetsought Black Poetry : A GRAND OLD MAN Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 1
OldSoul OldSoul : NOI Import Store Grand Opening 1972 OldSoul 1
Ankhur Black People : Grand plans to strategicaly mess with the planet Black People Open Forum 0
J Black Short Stories : The Grand Design Short Stories - Authors - Writing 2
skuderjaymes Black Entertainment : Wild Style.. Grand Master Flash Black Entertainment 0
skuderjaymes Science and Technology : Dr. Gabriel Oyibo.. Uniting Waves: Grand Unified Theorem Science and Technology 0
Knowledge Seed Black People : GRAND MASTER TEACHERS Black People Open Forum 9
G Black Events : Professor Oyibo, speaking on GAGUT (GOD Almighty's Grand Unified Theorem) this weeken Black Events 2
watzinaname Black Poetry : Grand Opening Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 25
Isaiah MAKE ME A GRAND BABY... Black Parenting 17
Isaiah Black Entertainment : GRAND MASTER FLASH & THE FURRIOUS FIVE... Black Entertainment 15
river Black Spirituality Religion : In the Grand Scheme of Things How Important Is America? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 4
Mad Skillz Black People : Are American Black Muslims Next In The Grand Scheme? Black People Open Forum 2
K Destee Network : Coming soon - Grand reopening Destee Network : 3
K Black People : Grand Scale Terrorism Black People Open Forum 0
M Black Poetry : The Thug Was Grand Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 4
B Black Poetry : Deception of Grand Scale Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 16
alyce Black Poetry : Cognac & Grand Marnier Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 8
W Black Poetry : cooley's grand exit Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 14
Clyde C Coger Jr Black Christians : Jury: Jehovah's Witnesses must pay $35M to abuse survivor Christian Study Group 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Black Positive People : Jury awards $289M to a black man who blames Roundup for cancer Black People Doing Positive Things 0
OldSoul OldSoul : Michael Slager Jury Foreman Speaks Out On Mistrial In Walter Scott Shooting OldSoul 0
shaka64 Black People : LA Jury Awards $5 Million to Funk Legend Sly Stone Black People Open Forum 5
shaka64 Law Forum : 'Loud Music' Murder Trial Resumes After Hung Jury Read more: Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 1
Similar threads

Latest profile posts

Cheryl Fitts wrote on Destee's profile.
I am looking for participants in a study to share their experiences as former African American males served as ED/EBD/BD in the southeast. Participants ages 18-35 will be interviewed and given the opportunity to express their thoughts, feelings and impressions of their school years. If interested or for more information please contact me directly. Thanks, Cheryl
Cheryl Fitts wrote on Destee's profile.
Thank you for the welcome. I have a question. I am a doctorate student in need of participants for my study. Is it allowable to post a request for study participants. If so, this is the post that would be uploaded:
Let's us all remember in 2021 to protect our energy and to do the best we can to grow and evolve.
Queen Destee im back still showing lo e after what 20+ yrs? You know always stop through from time to time
Destee wrote on rhymebad's profile.
@rhymebad ... i love you ... :love: ... what was going wrong about polls and being blocked and stuff?